A. Species
Scientific name: Carduelis spp and Fringilla spp.
Common name(s): Finches
Global IUCN Red List Threat Status:
B. Location of use
Geographic location(s):
- Italy (mainland)
- Malta
Country/Region: South-east and Central Europe
C. Scale of assessment
Scale of assessment: Regional/Continental/Multi-country level
Name/Details of location: South-east and Central Europe
D. Timescale of use
Start Year: 2001
End Year: 2006
E. Information about the use
How is the wild species sourced?: Wild species sourced from its natural habitat
Type of use: Extractive
Practice of use: Hunting and/or Trapping of live terrestrial and aerial animals
Lethal or non-lethal: Lethal
Does this use involve take/extraction of: The whole entire organism
Purpose(s) of end use: Food and feed
Motivation of use: Basic subsistence
Is this use legal or illegal?: Illegal under national law
F. Information about the Users
Which stakeholder(s) does the record primarily focus on?: International external
G. Information about the sustainability of use
Is there evidence that the use is having an impact on the target species?: Wild species sourced from its natural habitat
Has an assessment (or judgement) of sustainability of the use of the target species from an ecological perspective been recorded?: Yes, considered unsustainable
Details of assessment carried out: Analysis of seizures and prosecutions records by TRAFFIC (the Wildlife Trade Monitoring Network)
Brief summary on why the use has been assessed/judged to be sustainable or unsustainable: One of the rarest species hunted is the Red-breasted Goose (Branta ruficollis), classified as Endangered by IUCN. The European population of Corncrake (Crex crex) once numbered over 1 300 000 pairs, but suffered extreme declines in Europe from 1970-1990 mainly due to habitat loss. The population has still not recovered and is classified as ‘Depleted’ in Europe in the list of Species of European Conservation Concern. The situation is similar for European populations of Common Quail (Coturnix coturnix), especially in Central and Eastern Europe. [The report cautions that] Unless further attention is given to this trade, other European bird populations may meet the same fate – such as the European Turtle-dove (Streptopelia turtur). This species is classified as ‘Declining’, yet is in trade legally in significant numbers (e.g. as ‘hunting trophies’) and there are also very high levels of illegal trade. A substantial table is providing detailing 11 species that are impacted substantially.
Has an assessment (or judgement) of sustainability of the use of the target species from an economic perspective been recorded?: Yes, considered unsustainable
Details of assessment carried out: this study
Brief summary on why the use has been assessed/judged to be sustainable or unsustainable: The report cautions that although this use is traditional, these social and economic uses cannot be sustained in light of impacts on bird welfare and viability, and given that this activity is illegal under several acts of law.
Has an assessment (or judgement) of sustainability of the use of the target species from a social perspective been recorded?: Yes, considered unsustainable
Details of assessment carried out: this study
Brief summary on why the use has been assessed/judged to be sustainable or unsustainable: The report cautions that although this use is traditional, these social and economic uses cannot be sustained in light of impacts on bird welfare and viability, and given that this activity is illegal under several acts of law.
Has an assessment (or judgement) of sustainability of the use of the target species from a human health perspective been recorded?: not recorded
Details of assessment carried out: study does not record this
Brief summary on why the use has been assessed/judged to be sustainable or unsustainable: study does not record this
Has an assessment (or judgement) of sustainability of the use of the target species from an animal health/welfare perspective been recorded?: Yes, considered unsustainable
Details of assessment carried out: this study
Brief summary on why the use has been assessed/judged to be sustainable or unsustainable: The report cautions that although this use is traditional, these social and economic uses cannot be sustained in light of impacts on bird welfare and viability, and given that this activity is illegal under several acts of law.
Recommendations provided in the record to maintain or enhance the sustainability of the use of the target species
TRAFFIC calls upon wildlife management, scientific and enforcement bodies to pay focused attention to this illegal trade, with the following specific recommendations: 1. Italy and Malta should carry out focused activities to increase the awareness of consumers, enforcement officers and the judiciary about this illegal trade and its impact on wild populations, as well as taking measures against offenders; 2. Italy should promote an information campaign in collaboration with hunting agencies and hunters associations to inform hunters of national hunting laws outside of Italy; 3. Italian enforcement authorities should carry out focused inspections at border crossings based on risk analysis assessments;; 4. Enforcement officers in source, transit or final destination countries should be informed about and be on the look out for equipment used by illegal hunters, including nets, tape recorders, concealment methods, etc; 5. Consumer, transit and source countries should: a. Use existing channels, including workshops on more general wildlife trade issues, to exchange information regarding hunting and smuggling techniques, tools for identification and detection, and sharing intelligence, b. Make use of existing communication tools such as Interpol’s ECOMESSAGE, Customs’ Risk Information Forms and, for monitoring seizures, the European Union Trade in Wildlife Information eXchange (EU-TWIX) database, and 6. Wildlife management and scientific authorities should liaise with enforcement agencies to ensure that management plans take into account offtake from illegal activities. Management plans for migratory species (e.g. European Turtle-dove) should involve all geographical areas where the species migrate.
Record source
Information about the record source: grey_lit
Date of publication/issue/production: 2020-01-01T00:00:00+0000
Source Reference(s):
see: https://www.traffic.org/site/assets/files/3754/illegal_trade_wild_birds_for_food_europe.pdf
Date of record entry: 2022-11-10