Harvesting_Mushroom Coral_Indonesia

Affiliation
IIED
Type of wild species covered by the record
Wild species used in its natural habitat
Stage of the value chain covered by the record
Entire value chain
Record Source
Scientific publication (e.g., journal articles and book chapters independently peer-reviewed)

Live coral trade impacts on the mushroom coral Heliofungia actiniformis in Indonesia: Potential future management approaches

Unknown/not recorded
Is the species endemic HIDE
No
Population Status
Common and wildly distributed
Formal international protection in place
International Level
National Level
Formal national protection in place

The country’s guidelines for the sustainable utilization of coral resources also stipulates bestcollection practices including size limits, rotation of collection sites and the prohibition of coral collection in marine parks and tourist areas;

Additional Details (if available)

The poorly regulated aquarium trade in live corals poses yet another threat to fragile coral reef ecosystems. in the archipelago, reef degradation is widespread, with causes including indus- trial and sewage pollution from nearby Makassar, extensive bomb fishing, anchor damage and over-harvesting of coral reef resources

Population Trend
Unknown/not recorded
Sub-national Level
Unknown/not recorded
Additional Details (if available)

In one study, 1% of the specimens were recorded as bleached (Hoeksema 1991).
This species is targeted for the aquarium trade. Indonesia is the largest exporter with an annual quota of 48,500 live pieces in 2005. The total number of corals (live and raw) exported for this species in 2005 was 51,518. This species is one of the top ten most traded corals for aquarium industry (Raymakers 2001).
In general, the major threat to corals is global climate change, in particular, temperature extremes leading to bleaching and increased susceptibility to disease, increased severity of ENSO events and storms, and ocean acidification.
Coral disease has emerged as a serious threat to coral reefs worldwide and a major cause of reef deterioration (Weil et al. 2006). The numbers of diseases and coral species affected, as well as the distribution of diseases have all increased dramatically within the last decade;

Name
Emma Hemmerlé
Scientific Name
Heliofungia actiniformis
Common Name(s)
Mushroom coral
Type of Use
Extractive (i.e., the entire organism or parts of the organism are removed from its environment)
If extractive, for the target species, is this use
Non-Lethal
Does this use involve take/extraction of
The whole entire organism
Are specific characteristics/traits being targeted?
Yes

polys of certain colors and/or size are preferentially selected for the lice coral aquarium trade;

Purpose of Use
Basic subsistence (meeting day to day essential needs)
Income generation from trade at individual or household or community
Largescale commercial exploitation for trade
Additional Details (if available)

aquarium trade in live corals

Amount
9500.00
Units Of Measurement
annual quota for number of pieces of mushroom coral from South Sulawesi
Time period over which this has been recorded
2004 to 2006
What is the trend in the level of offtake within the period covered by this record?
Additional Details (if available)

The Indonesian authorities routinely allocate some of the highest trade quotas in South Sulawesi to Heliofungia actiniformis despite a lack of data on the impacts of current collection practices on this species.

Provide Details of resource rights regime where relevant

some of the fishermen interviewed were licensed, while others were unlicensed; Overall, a much higher number of H. actiniformis than allowed by current quotas is thus being harvested.

Geographic Location
Country
Indonesia
Sub region/state
South Sulawesi
Name
Spermonde Archipelago
Site Description

The archipelago extends approximately 60 km offshore and consists of about 150 coral cays, as well as a large number of barrier and submerged patch reefs

Local people (e.g., individuals, communities, co-operatives)
National / local private sector
Is the use part of a strategy to generate conservation incentives, to finance conservation, or to improve tolerance/stewardship?
Unknown/not recorded
Is there evidence that the use is affecting the conservation status of the species? HIDE
Yes – use is negatively affecting the status (e.g., population is declining; extraction effort is increasing)
Is there evidence that the use is affecting natural selection?
Unknown/not recorded
Is there evidence that the use is affecting poaching of illegal wildlife trade?
Unknown/not reported
Is there any evidence that this use of the species is having a knock-on effect on the status of non-target species
Unknown/not recorded
Unknown/not recorded
Details of assessment carried out

current collection quotas are designated as arbitrary values from an ecological point of view;

Has a valuation of financial flows from this use at the site/national/international level been recorded
No
Contribution to GDP
Unknown/not recorded
Medicine/healthcare
Training/Skills
Land/Resource Rights
Decision Making
Social Cohesion
Conflict- people
Conflict- wildlife
Climate Change
Details of assessment

A predictive model indicated the need for a 5 cm size limit to curb economic overfishing, and protect attached anthocauli stalks capable of maintaining the trade through continued asexual reproduction. In addition, a reduction of exploitation rates for polyps in the 4–11 cm size bracket to 0.5 is urgently needed. Calculations reveal that this would in fact be possible without lowering current profits. Achieving long term sustainability will in addition to a reduction of harvest quotas necessitate an effective protection of spawning stocks through stricter enforcement of existing marine protected areas.

Has the use of the species been recorded as resulting in changes to human health in this record?
Unknown/not recorded
Has the species in use been noted as being of particular disease risk to humans?
Unknown/not recorded
Has the use of the species resulted in changes to animal welfare in this record?
Unknown/not recorded
Are there particular practices which have increased the risk to human or animal health or welfare in the use of this species?
Unknown/not recorded
Does the use of this species increase susceptibility to pathogen spread?
Unknown/not recorded
Unknown/not recorded
Biological characteristics of target species
Absent
Source Reference(s)

Knittweis, L., & Wolff, M. (2010). Live coral trade impacts on the mushroom coral Heliofungia actiniformis in Indonesia: Potential future management approaches. Biological Conservation, 143(11), 2722-2729. doi: 10.1016/j.biocon.2010.07.019

Semi-structured interviews with fishermen and in situ surveys revealed a size-selective fishery towards small polyps. This resulted in a shift of size-frequency distributions, and reduced overall abun- dances at harvested sites.
The age frequency structure of H. actiniformis polyps showed populations dominated by young, attached individuals at harvested sites; fishermen do not wait for the young polyps to break free from their anthocauli, but frequently beak off entire clusters with the anthocauli still attached. Only the largest polyps which have developed a flat base are kept, whilst the rest are discarded on site.
Based on the results of this investigation, harvest quotas for H. actiniformis should be reduced significantly.

Threats/pressures impacting the species at the scale of this record
Who is involved in the use?
Is there any gender/age specificity in the various roles
Unknown/not recorded
How many of these local jobs accure to the following categories?
How many people outside the local area are employed
Is there any evidence of other economic benefits associated with this use beyond direct income and jobs
Unknown/Not recorded
Scale of Assessment
IUCN National Red List Category
IUCN Global Red List Category
Green Status Global Category
Yearly Financial Flows
Other
Human Intrusions and disturbances
Yes, considered unsustainable
Yes, considered unsustainable
Country reference